My Cart
Close
Stationery For Her
Cards
Gifts
Journals
Notebooks
Note Sets
Pens
For Him
For The Hostess
Gifts
Gifts for the Bride
Gifts for Baby
Gifts for Her
Gifts for Him
Books
Holiday
Home Decor
Sports
Stationery
Food
Candy
Jalapeno Cheddar Straws
Peanuts
For The Bride
For The Home
Bar
Bath
Books
Custom
Decor
Entertaining
Gifts
Holiday
Office
Outdoor
Travel
For Baby
Boy
Girl
Neutral
Mom
Gifts Under $50
For the Bride
For the Baby
For Her
For Him
For the Bath
For the Home
For the Holidays
View our Coronavirus Response
ACCOUNT
CART
The Gift Shoppe
Best Sellers
For Her
For Him
For Baby & Child
For Brides
Gifts Under $50
Buy a Gift Card
The Stationery Shoppe
For The Home
Decor
Entertaining/Bar
Drinkware
Linens
Seasonal
Books, Games & Puzzles
Candles & Home Fragrance
Bath
The Style Shoppe
Jewelry
Accessories
Made in the South
Buttercup Exclusives
Local Artists
Southern Snacks
North Carolina
Gameday
About Us
History
FAQs
Contact Us
Buttercup Exclusives
Sort by
Featured
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Best Selling
Easter Basket
$95.00
QUICK VIEW
Chocolate Chip Cookies 10 oz.
From $13.95 - $14.95
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Chocolate Chip Cookies 2 oz
$4.95
QUICK VIEW
College Towns Framed Acrylic Pictures
$34.95
QUICK VIEW
Buttercup Peanut Collection
From $15.95 - $18.95
QUICK VIEW
Hand Knitted Christmas Stockings
$175.00
QUICK VIEW
Chocolate Chip Cookies half gallon
$23.95
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Chocolate Chip Cookies 5 oz
$9.95
QUICK VIEW
Graybill & Downs Candle
$45.00
QUICK VIEW
Gold Plaquesw Sayings
$24.00
QUICK VIEW
Cross Wreath
$58.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Amanda Earrings
$39.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Roxie Earring
$42.00
QUICK VIEW
Graybill & Downs Diffuser
$60.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Daphne Earrings
$32.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Miranda Earrings
$36.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Stud Muffin Earring
$32.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Art on Canvas 6x6
$60.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Wreath 6 Inches
$45.00
QUICK VIEW
Vivian Hawaiian Navy Earrings
$39.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Emma Earrings Leopard Marigold Stamp Sage Clover Farm
$42.00
QUICK VIEW
Sold Out
Dorothy Earring Vivi
$42.00
QUICK VIEW
Hazel Earring
$42.00
QUICK VIEW
Marie Earrings Orange Vivian Wood
$39.00
QUICK VIEW
Peyton Earring
$39.00
QUICK VIEW
Ryan Earrings
$42.00
QUICK VIEW
Botanical Heart on 5x7 Acrylic Frame
$75.00
QUICK VIEW
Funky Road Tote Turqoise Cowhide
$108.95
QUICK VIEW
Graybill & Downs Large Candle
$75.00
QUICK VIEW
Abby Earring Zebra
$42.00
QUICK VIEW
Showing items 1-30 of 30.